Oko lecture

May Oko Lecture – Reply to Matsuno

May 11, 2025

Lecture in Praise of Nichiren Daishonin
May Oko Lecture
Published in the July 2025 Nichiren Shoshu Monthly

“Reply to Matsuno”
(“Matsuno dono-gohenji”)

Alternative title: “The Fourteen Slanders”
(“Jushi hibo-sho”)

You wrote in your letter: “Ever since I embraced this sutra, I have never neglected to recite the ten factors (junyoze) and verses (Jigage) and to chant Daimoku. However, how significant is the difference between the benefits of the Daimoku when a sage chants and when we chant?” There is no superiority or inferiority between them. That is to say, gold in the hands of a fool is the same as that possessed by a wise man. Likewise, a fire lit by a fool cannot be distinguished from one ignited by someone wise. But there is a difference if one chants while opposing the spirit of this sutra.

(Gosho, p. 1046)

Background and Summary

This Gosho was written on the ninth day of the 12th month of the second year of Kenji (1276), when the Daishonin was 55 years of age, two years following his entry into Mt. Minobu. It was a letter delivered by his disciple Sammi-bo to Matsuno Rokuro-saemon, who was the lord of Matsuno of the Ihara District (present-day Fuji City, Shizuoka Prefecture). It was a response to a previous letter from Lord Matsuno. Based on its contents, it is alternatively titled “The Fourteen Slanders” (“Jushi hobo”).

In this Gosho, the Daishonin warns us not to commit the 14 slanders and teaches us the importance of cultivating a seeking spirit for the Law, as he relays the ancient story about Sessen Doji. He instructs the priests to propagate the Law, even at the risk of their lives. He teaches the lay believers the importance of chanting sincere Daimoku, presenting heartfelt Gokuyo offerings, and propagating the Law according to their strengths. Finally, he expounds that by upholding this practice, people will be able to attain enlightenment at the end of their lives.

Essential Points of the Lecture

The Admonishment of “Whether it is True or Not”

Lord Matsuno asked Nichiren Daishonin to explain how much of a difference there is between the benefits of the Daimoku chanted by him, the Daishonin, and that of the Daimoku voiced by others. In response, he expounds, “There is no superiority or inferiority between them.” However, the Daishonin explains that there is a difference in the benefits if one chants while opposing “the spirit of this sutra,” and he discusses the 14 slanders as concrete, negative causes.

In this Gosho, the Daishonin also mentions the phrase “whether it is true or not” from the Encouragements of Bodhisattva Universally Worthy (Fugen bosatsu kanbotsu; twenty-eighth) chapter of the Lotus Sutra. (Hokekyo, p. 606) The Daishonin teaches that, whether or not the criticism is valid, slighting those who believe in true Buddhism is tantamount to disparaging the Buddha and constitutes tremendous slander. We aim to achieve the Daishonin’s great objective of kosen-rufu and uphold our faith and practice as we achieve this precious mission. Therefore, we must respect and support each other, as we joyfully and enthusiastically advance with courage by forming true unity characterized by many in body, on in mind (itai doshin).

Engaging With Our Utmost Power in the Actual Practice of Shakubuku 

The Daishonin states the following about the faith believers should uphold:

It is essential for you, as a lay believer, to single-mindedly chant Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo and also make offerings to the priests. Furthermore, in order to practice exactly as the [Lotus] Sutra teaches, you must propagate the Law to the full extent of your ability.

(Gosho, p. 1051)

In other words, it is essential to chant sincere Daimoku, offer Gokyo to the Gohonzon, and powerfully engage in shakubuku.

Accomplishing shakubuku is dependent on actual practice. The mystic Law (Myoho) of the Daishonin enables the salvation of both those who directly embrace it and those who oppose it. Therefore, there is absolutely no waste in the actual practice of shakubuku.

The Daishonin states the following in the Gosho:

Practice without faltering until the final moment of your life, and then, take in the view around you [of the land of eternally tranquil light].

(Gosho, p. 1051)

Here, he points to the land of eternally tranquil light, which can be seen when the universe is perceived through the eyes of Buddhahood. Nikken Shonin, the Sixty-seventh High Priest of the Head Temple, said:

Let us all exert our utmost efforts in our faith and practice so that we can achieve a life condition like this as soon as possible, without having to wait until the moment of our death.

(Dainichiren, May 1993, p. 67)

We uphold faith to attain Buddhahood in this lifetime and to achieve kosen-rufu. Let us never lose sight of this and challenge ourselves to accomplish shakubuku, refuting heresy and revealing the truth, as we polish and improve our faith. Let’s uphold a powerful determination to do shakubuku no matter what.

Guidance From High Priest Nichinyo Shonin

If slander is not refuted, it can never be eliminated. Then, who can refute slander? We are the ones. We are the only ones. Therefore, we must be convinced to denounce the slanders of heretical doctrines and religions. The true Law will be propagated through such denunciation, giving rise to a truly peaceful world.

(Dainichiren, February 2025, pp. 17-18)

Conclusion

Inviting our families, relatives, and acquaintances to our Buddhist activities is an excellent opportunity to strengthen our ties with them. As we have been facing tragic news recently around the world, let us muster our courage and engage in conversations that will lead to planting the seed of Buddhism, so that, first and foremost, we can protect those closest to us. Then, let us strive to expand that circle even a little at a time. Doing so will eventually spread that circle into various regions and nations, ultimately leading to kosen-rufu.


Footnote:

Explanation 

In your letter, you said: “Since I embraced the Lotus Sutra, I have not slackened in my faith and have continued to recite the Hoben and Juryo verses and chanted the Daimoku. I want to ask you how much difference there is between the benefits of the Daimoku that you, the sage, chant, and the Daimoku that we chant?” There is no disparity between the benefits. That is to say, it is like the gold held by a fool that is in no way different from the gold held by a wise person. And there is no distinction between a fire lit by a fool and one lit by a wise man. However, there will be a disparity if one chants the Daimoku while turning his back on the spirit of the Lotus Sutra.

Explanation of the Major Terms 

  • Ten Factors (Junyoze): This refers to the Expedient Means (Hoben; second) chapter of the Lotus Sutra. The ten factors indicate the body and mind’s characteristics and functions. The ten are: appearance (nyoze so); nature (nyoze sho); entity (nyoze tai); power (nyoze riki); influence (nyoze sa); internal cause (nyoze in); relation (nyoze en); latent effect (nyoze ka); manifest effect (nyoze ho); and consistency from beginning to end (nyoze hommatsu kukyoto).
  • Verses (Jigage): The passage from “Ji ga toku burrai” to “Soku joju busshin” in the Life Span of the Tathagata (Nyorai juryo; sixteenth) chapter of the Lotus Sutra. The character ge in Jigage stands for “verse” (geju), which refers to the gaatha verse [in Sanskrit]. The verses are poetic stanzas that praise the virtues and doctrines of the Buddha. They expound the permanence of the Buddha’s entity and the permanence of the objective, insentient world.
  • Fourteen Slanders: Fourteen types of slander against true Buddhism: 1) arrogance – to be conceited and to despise true Buddhism; 2) negligence – to neglect one’s Buddhist practce; 3) arbitrary, egotistical judgment – to make assumptions about true Buddhism through one’s arbitrary perspectives; 4) shallow, self-satisfied understanding – to judge true Buddhism based on shallow knowledge, without a profound seeking spirit; 5) attachment to earthly desires – to be attached to one’s desires and making light of true Buddhism; 6) lack of understanding without a seeking spirit – to make no effort to understand true Buddhism; 7) disbelief – to not believe in true Buddhism; 8) aversion – to frown upon and criticize true Buddhism; 9) deluded doubt – to doubt true Buddhism; 10) vilification – to speak ill of true Buddhism; 11) contempt – to have contempt for those who uphold true Buddhism; 12) hatred – to hate those who uphold true Buddhism; 13) jealousy – to be jealous of those who uphold true Buddhism; 14) grudges – to bear a grudge against those who uphold true Buddhism.